I am struggling with this question right now and that's why I joined joined this forum....looking for opinions. I have an order for 2 dozen cookies for 4th of July and half of them are graphics (vintage post cards) and half of them will be photographs. I did a test today using frosting sheets from kopycake and they worked well with the graphics. And I understand that the frosting sheets will also be better with photos. I just ordered some wafer sheets and want to test those out as well. I am most interested in the consistency and taste with the cookie as well as appearance. I know I can make them LOOK good, but I want them to taste and feel good in the mouth as well.