Malay's Village in the Evening

Julia M. Usher posted:

Hi, Patty, this is a lovely cookie, but I don't think it fits the challenge guidelines insofar as they only allow one non-stenciled element on the cookie, and I see at least two here: painted houses and piped leaves.  I am deleting it from the challenge for this reason, but correct me if I am wrong.

This IS a lovely cookie.  However, unfortunately, I agree with Julia.

Julia M. Usher posted:

Patty's Cookies posted:

Julia M. Usher posted:

Hi, Patty, this is a lovely cookie, but I don't think it fits the challenge guidelines insofar as they only allow one non-stenciled element on the cookie, and I see at least two here: painted houses and piped leaves.  I am deleting it from the challenge for this reason, but correct me if I am wrong.

owh... thanks Julia, i must have overlooked that particular guideline. 

So sorry, but, yes, it's rule #3: "3.  Although a scene created entirely with stencils is preferred in this challenge, you may include one, and only one, additional medium, such as the fondant mermaid tail in our example."

Again, I am sorry, but I have to apply the rules per the letter; otherwise, I run the risk of others getting upset with me for not being fair. I hope you'll understand. Perhaps you can do another version without all of the piped detail and re-submit?

No worries , i understand that . perhaps i will try again if i can make it before the closing date. once again, thanks  and have a great day.

Manu posted:

Very nice!

Thank you 

Very nice!

Hi, Patty, this is a lovely cookie, but I don't think it fits the challenge guidelines insofar as they only allow one non-stenciled element on the cookie, and I see at least two here: painted houses and piped leaves.  I am deleting it from the challenge for this reason, but correct me if I am wrong.

Fabulous 

Patty's Cookies posted:

Julia M. Usher posted:

Hi, Patty, this is a lovely cookie, but I don't think it fits the challenge guidelines insofar as they only allow one non-stenciled element on the cookie, and I see at least two here: painted houses and piped leaves.  I am deleting it from the challenge for this reason, but correct me if I am wrong.

owh... thanks Julia, i must have overlooked that particular guideline. 

So sorry, but, yes, it's rule #3: "3.  Although a scene created entirely with stencils is preferred in this challenge, you may include one, and only one, additional medium, such as the fondant mermaid tail in our example."

Again, I am sorry, but I have to apply the rules per the letter; otherwise, I run the risk of others getting upset with me for not being fair. I hope you'll understand. Perhaps you can do another version without all of the piped detail and re-submit?

Julia M. Usher posted:

Hi, Patty, this is a lovely cookie, but I don't think it fits the challenge guidelines insofar as they only allow one non-stenciled element on the cookie, and I see at least two here: painted houses and piped leaves.  I am deleting it from the challenge for this reason, but correct me if I am wrong.

owh... thanks Julia, i must have overlooked that particular guideline. 

Teri Pringle Wood posted:

Fabulous 

Thank you 

Beautiful work

swissophie posted:

So beautiful and cleverly made! Love how you give depth with the framing plants. Very lovely, serene scene!

Thank you so much. 

Evelindecora posted:

Lovely!!! ❤️

thanks  Evelin

CHELY Morales posted:

Muy bonito y buen trabajo!

Thank you so much 

Bakerloo Station posted:

Julia M. Usher posted:

Hi, Patty, this is a lovely cookie, but I don't think it fits the challenge guidelines insofar as they only allow one non-stenciled element on the cookie, and I see at least two here: painted houses and piped leaves.  I am deleting it from the challenge for this reason, but correct me if I am wrong.

This IS a lovely cookie.  However, unfortunately, I agree with Julia.

thanks Christine

Lovely!!! ❤️

So beautiful and cleverly made! Love how you give depth with the framing plants. Very lovely, serene scene!

Muy bonito y buen trabajo!

Supporting process image, below.