I understand your stress and predicament. I agree that you need to either refund the customer for the cost of the broken cookies or send replacements. To avoid having to deal with the breakage issue, I only sell cookies to local customers and they either pick up the order or I deliver and charge mileage. Also, preparing a package for shipment requires shipping materials which is costly and packaging takes precious time. When I receive an inquiry from someone who is not local, I suggest they search online for a cookie decorator in their vicinity. Good luck! Joan-My Cookie Clinic