Skip to main content

So, I just recently purchased a bottle of Lorann Preserve-It Antioxidant from Amazon.com. I've been interested in trying to add a preservative to my cookie recipe as many people tend to save their cookies for a month (or more!) before deciding to consume them. Well, this bothers me because after about a week I can tell the difference in quality of my cookies and can't imagine what they must be like after a month. I understand that a no-chemical-added recipe is probably more appealing than one that is unnatural but I decided to play with artificial variation of Lorann's Antioxidant because it is substantially cheaper. Anyway, I was wondering if anyone has had any experience with either variation or any other type of preservative in their sugar cookie recipe and what that might be. I'm excited to see what the outcome will be as having a longer shelf-life will put my mind a bit more at ease when people decide to eat my cookies a while after they receive them. If it works out I may consider spending a bit more on the natural version of the antioxidant.

 

I am also open to any pros and cons that people may have with putting a preservative in their recipe. Besides the "not being all natural" part, I'm not sure what else would be a problem with it.

 

Happy baking!

-Michelle

Sweet Somethings by Michelle

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

This is very intriguing. I've never seen the preservative, let alone tried it. But I would say it's definitely worth a try! While it's wonderful to be able to say your cookies are "all natural", I'd rather they just tasted really good for as long as possible.

I have not used it, but from what others have told me about preseratives, I am not sure how much you would have to add, but they can negativly alter the taste of your cookies.

 

My cookies tend to have a 30 day shelf-life, but it would be NICE to have them last longer...make sure to let us all know the outcome! Also, take note on the taste...I am curious if that view-point is accurate...

Cool! Looking forward to next week's update!
Originally Posted by Michelle from Sweet Somethings:

A little update...the cookies taste the same 2 days in. Texture is good too. Ill check it again in a week (when I normally notice a difference in quality).

 

Another update...it's been a week since the cookies were baked and though the texture seems slightly crunchier than day 7/31 and 8/2, the stale butter flavor (I think) I was normally tasting after about a week is not there. Will check back again in week for those interested!

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×