Skip to main content

Hello, fellow cookiers! I could really use your help...


I made a large batch of cookies, and after outlining and flooding the cookies, the icing never completely set. I can stack them and they're reasonably firm, but they're still a little tacky on top and marshmallowy underneath the top layer of icing. Since other cookies I made set just fine, I think I may have thrown off the meringue powder-sugar-water ratios in that batch of icing, making them not set properly.


My question was about the safety of these cookies. Is royal icing like buttercream, where the safety of it is determined by the amount of sugar in the recipe? Could this problem be indicative of a food safety concern? Thank you so much!

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

If you're using meringue powder and not raw egg whites, then there's no potential carrier of salmonella (which is carried in raw, not pasteurized or dehydrated, eggs), but you can still cross-contaminate (introduce bacteria to) any food product if you handle it improperly (i.e., don't wash hands, get something else in it). Products with high concentrations of sugar can suppress bacterial growth but they are never a complete preventative. Proper handling to avoid cross-contamination is always important. In this case, if you handled everything carefully, there's probably not much to worry about.

Cookies From Home posted:

Better if you can use raw white egg rather than powder.I agree with admit that sugar products can suppress bacterial growth.It is important to add exact amount of ingredients in your recipe.

Cookie Gifts

This is not accurate if you are talking about the risk of salmonella in whites. Powdered whites are dehydrated, and thus any bacteria in them is potentially killed during this heating process. Powdered whites are generally safer than unpasteurized, raw whites.

Add Reply

Link copied to your clipboard.